Search Your Destination Now!

Beaver Island Rentals

Rental Rates ($USD weekly)

Guests

Check Rates & Availability:

Update Results Reset Dates
Filter

Results: 49 Rentals

  • Convenient in town location
    From $150 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Convenient in town location

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    4

    Located on beautiful Beaver Island in Lake Michigan. Take advantage of beautiful sunrise/sunsets, hiking, boating, fishi ...

    From $150 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Starry Skies Sanctuary-Luxury Lakefront Home on Lake Geneserath w\/Watercrafts
    From $436 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Starry Skies Sanctuary-Luxury Lakefront Home on Lake Geneserath w\/Watercrafts

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    7
    Sleeps:
    10

    “Five star home and host” This lakefront luxury retreat was newly renovated in 2021. If you are looking for a calm and r ...

    From $436 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Rustic Authentic Michigan Log Cabin
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Rustic Authentic Michigan Log Cabin

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    2

    Get Away to an unspoiled environment, a place that has been virtually untouched, that is Beaver Island. Our cabin (Kelly ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Lakefront Cottage
    From $318 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Lakefront Cottage

    Bedrooms:
    4
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    8

    Windwood Cottage is a gorgeous custom home, located at the shores of Lake Michigan on one of the most beautifully seclud ...

    From $318 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Convenient Beaver Island Location
    From $179 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Convenient Beaver Island Location

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    6

    Freesoil House rental offers a convenient and comfortable place to stay with or without a vehicle. We welcome you to enj ...

    From $179 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Deckhand's Quarters @The Boat Shop overlooking Paradise Bay
    From $174 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Deckhand's Quarters @The Boat Shop overlooking Paradise Bay

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    5

    We welcome you to enjoy your vacation in this beautiful two-bedroom rental in the heart of downtown Beaver Island. Locat ...

    From $174 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Lakefront Cottage on Soft Sand
    From $264 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Lakefront Cottage on Soft Sand

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    11

    Located in the middle of Sand Bay, 5 miles from down town, 3 miles from the golf course and steps from150 feet of sandy ...

    From $264 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Lake Michigan\/Beaver Island with incredible private beach
    From $414 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Lake Michigan\/Beaver Island with incredible private beach

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    5
    Sleeps:
    14

    Want to get away from it all? Come unplug on Beaver Island with beautiful four bedroom, three bath home right on Lake Mi ...

    From $414 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Gorgeous Rustic Northern Michigan Island Getaway
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Gorgeous Rustic Northern Michigan Island Getaway

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    Get Away to an unspoiled natural environment where several eagle sitings daily are common. A place that has been virtual ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Starry Night. Spacious and relaxing guesthouse. WiFi. 2 miles from town.
    From $123 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Starry Night. Spacious and relaxing guesthouse. WiFi. 2 miles from town.

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    4

    A vintage vacation awaits you. 32 mi offshore on America's emerald isle, Beaver Island. Unspoiled. Unhurried. Unbelievab ...

    From $123 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Sunny Oaks. Bright, beautiful, in town. Wifi.
    From $154 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Sunny Oaks. Bright, beautiful, in town. Wifi.

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    6

    Take the ferry or plane from Charlevoix to experience island paradise. A vintage vacation awaits you. Beaver Island, 32 ...

    From $154 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Lovely Apartment Over Looking Font Lake
    From $132 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Lovely Apartment Over Looking Font Lake

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    4

    Finished in 2014, above-garage apartment, full kitchen with all amenities, one bedroom (plus queen size fold-out couc ...

    From $132 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • View of the  the bay is worth the stay.  Beaver Island Harbor View Cottage
    From $230 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    View of the the bay is worth the stay. Beaver Island Harbor View Cottage

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    6

    A view of the bay is worth the stay! A breath-taking view (180°) of the beaver island harbor (Paradise Bay) overlooking ...

    From $230 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Unique, Attractive Hexagon Cedar Lodge in the Woods
    From $130 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Unique, Attractive Hexagon Cedar Lodge in the Woods

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    5

    TARA'S MEADOW nonprofit with its Cedar Lodge in the Woods, and its 30 acre Nature Sanctuary offers guests a one-of-a kin ...

    From $130 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Expansive views of the whole Harbor and Whiskey Point Light house.
    From $434 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Expansive views of the whole Harbor and Whiskey Point Light house.

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    5
    Sleeps:
    15

    Arrive on the ferry to beautiful Beaver Island and walk a short distance to vacation home. Enjoy a beautiful view of Jam ...

    From $434 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Captain's Quarters @The Boat Shop - Overlooking Paradise Bay
    From $152 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Captain's Quarters @The Boat Shop - Overlooking Paradise Bay

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    2

    We welcome you to enjoy your vacation in this beautiful one-bedroom apartment in the heart of downtown Beaver Island. Lo ...

    From $152 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Beaver Harbor Condo Unit #5 with semi-private beachfront access
    From $150 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Beaver Harbor Condo Unit #5 with semi-private beachfront access

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    4

    Cozy and quaint, this 2 bed, 1 bathroom condo with sleeping for four is a perfect family getaway. One bedroom has a quee ...

    From $150 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Paradise Bay Retreat
    From $329 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Paradise Bay Retreat

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    10

    Welcome to the amazing Harbor district of Beaver Island, a vibrant location just past the Whiskey Point Brewing Company ...

    From $329 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Beaver Island - Cable Bay Cottage
    From $290 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Beaver Island - Cable Bay Cottage

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    If you're looking to get away from it all, this is the place for you! Offering a private, sandy beach on one of the isl ...

    From $290 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Beautiful Beaver Island getaway
    From $170 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Beautiful Beaver Island getaway

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    This property sits on 3 1/2 acres of wooded privacy. You are less than 2 miles from town. You are less than a mile away ...

    From $170 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Beaver Island Chalet 2BR, 2BA sleeps 6, big windows overlooking lovely woods.
    From $281 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Beaver Island Chalet 2BR, 2BA sleeps 6, big windows overlooking lovely woods.

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    6

    Beaver Island Chalet is full of light, set in a beautiful wooded cove. Windows surround the open, spacious living area. ...

    From $281 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Lake View Cottage on Beautiful Sand Bay
    From $233 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Lake View Cottage on Beautiful Sand Bay

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    7

    This is a cute cozy cottage with a lake view of Lake Michigan! It’s a 2 minute walk to a beautiful secluded public beach ...

    From $233 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Home away from home. Well maintained and close to the main road.
    From $223 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Home away from home. Well maintained and close to the main road.

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    8

    NOTE: This is a SUNDAY to SUNDAY rental from May to October. This 3 bedroom, 2 1/2 bath cottage was fully restored in t ...

    From $223 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Rare and newly updated Lake Michigan home with breath taking sunsets.
    From $293 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Rare and newly updated Lake Michigan home with breath taking sunsets.

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    6

    Private Lake Michigan cottage with beautiful sunsets, and nature at your door steps. 100 feet of Lake MI frontage with a ...

    From $293 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Spectacular Views of Paradise Bay
    From $438 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Spectacular Views of Paradise Bay

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    8

    This ideal house is located close to town (1.5 miles away) with private waterfront access and views of Paradise Bay. Yo ...

    From $438 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Beautiful Home With Harbor View! Warm and cozy cottage.
    From $311 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Beautiful Home With Harbor View! Warm and cozy cottage.

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    6

    Remodeled home on beautiful St. James harbor Beaver Island, 2019 completion. Gorgeous! This home has the warmth and ch ...

    From $311 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Beachfront paradise on Lake Michigan
    From $318 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Beachfront paradise on Lake Michigan

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    8

    Beaver Island is the perfect place to reset and recharge! This two bedroom with loft and two bathroom home is set up to ...

    From $318 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Indoor\/outdoor living at its best in this stunning lakeside home.
    From $998 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Indoor\/outdoor living at its best in this stunning lakeside home.

    Bedrooms:
    5
    Bathrooms:
    7
    Sleeps:
    15

    This home was designed with your relaxation and rejuvenation in mind. Each room provides stunning views of the lake or w ...

    From $998 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Lake Shore Stay- on the shore of Lake Michigan, Beaver Island, MI
    From $197 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Lake Shore Stay- on the shore of Lake Michigan, Beaver Island, MI

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    2

    The most common remark on entering the 1,000 sq foot apartment is WOW! Or Stunning! Located on beautiful Lake Michigan o ...

    From $197 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • The Fisherman’s House\nHistoric Beaver Island home from 1906
    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    The Fisherman’s House\nHistoric Beaver Island home from 1906

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    8

    This historic Beaver Island home was built in 1906, but moved to its new location in October 2022. Just off of the main ...

    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Details
  • Top Deck!!
    From $311 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Top Deck!!

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    4

    We welcome you to enjoy your vacation in this beautiful 2 bedroom rental in the heart of downtown Beaver Island. Located ...

    From $311 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • ALL DECKED OUT is a fun, bright, and beautiful home in town.
    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    ALL DECKED OUT is a fun, bright, and beautiful home in town.

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    7

    ALL DECKED OUT is a fun, bright, and beautiful 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath home that comfortably sleeps 6. We are located on a q ...

    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Details
  • Southern Most Beach House
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Southern Most Beach House

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    8

    Note: Please check ferry schedule before booking Sept/Oct. House which sits high above the dunes has a short walk to its ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Northern Lights House
    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Northern Lights House

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    10

    Note to please check ferry schedule Sept/Oct before booking. This location is a favorite spot as it puts you within walk ...

    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Details
  • 🍀 The Lucky Charm on Beaver Island's Lake Geneserath!
    From $317 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    🍀 The Lucky Charm on Beaver Island's Lake Geneserath!

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    8

    Step back to quieter times on peaceful Lake Geneserath! Located on the sunny south end of Beaver Island is Hemlock Point ...

    From $317 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Shadwell, beautiful private setting on Font Lake
    From $271 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Shadwell, beautiful private setting on Font Lake

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    8

    New to VRBO, this home has been used by family and friends for many years and is a very special place. Large 4 bedroom h ...

    From $271 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • 2-bed cottage on Cable's Bay with private beach
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    2-bed cottage on Cable's Bay with private beach

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    4

    New listing! Enjoy beautiful lake views and your own private beach at this dog-friendly 2-bed, 1-bath cottage on Cable's ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Beautiful, well maintained home on Lake Michigan at Indian Point!
    From $275 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Beautiful, well maintained home on Lake Michigan at Indian Point!

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    8

    Indian Point of View, our home on Beaver Island has 2 bedrooms with one having a queen bed and the other a King Bed; a l ...

    From $275 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Beautiful Lake Michigan Views! Island Windsong Beachfront Home on Beaver Island
    From $546 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Beautiful Lake Michigan Views! Island Windsong Beachfront Home on Beaver Island

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    6

    Welcome to Island Windsong! Unplug for the winter in this beautiful Sand Bay waterfront home. Wake up to beautiful winte ...

    From $546 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Bungalow Wicklow Lake Michigan Beaver Island House
    From $344 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Bungalow Wicklow Lake Michigan Beaver Island House

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    5

    Prepare to be amazed!!! This remarkable house is perfectly positioned on the bank of Lake Michigan, offering you the mos ...

    From $344 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Trails End of Beaver Island Michigan
    From $253 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Trails End of Beaver Island Michigan

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    10

    Trails End of Beaver Island Michigan. A remote Island 30 miles off the coast of Lake Michigan. Trails End is convenientl ...

    From $253 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Cozy beachfront cottage with Sun and Moonrise
    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Cozy beachfront cottage with Sun and Moonrise

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    6

    Enjoy your coffee on the deck, walks on the beach, exploring the Island, reading, enjoying nature, kayaking, playing gam ...

    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Details
  • Southern Most Beach House
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Southern Most Beach House

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    8

    Note: Please check ferry schedule before booking Sept/Oct. House which sits high above the dunes has a short walk to its ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Burtonport: Make some memories at this unique, family-friendly place.
    From $209 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Burtonport: Make some memories at this unique, family-friendly place.

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    Make some memories at this unique and family-friendly place. This rental is located a mile out of town at our island's a ...

    From $209 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Sunsets, Sandy Beach and Seclusion; enjoy them all at this stunning lake house
    From $464 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Sunsets, Sandy Beach and Seclusion; enjoy them all at this stunning lake house

    Bedrooms:
    4
    Bathrooms:
    6
    Sleeps:
    12

    Green Woods Over The Waves is an unforgettable lakefront getaway situated on 5.5 acres with 400 feet of private, sandy L ...

    From $464 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Waterfront
    From $292 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Waterfront

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    4

    The.Sandpiper.House Cozy and peaceful home for rent on Donegal Bay. This 2 bedroom get away has all the amenities you n ...

    From $292 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • The Guest House Beaver Island, MI
    From $297 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    The Guest House Beaver Island, MI

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    8

    Beaver Island Lake Michigan Vacation House!!! Let that sink in!!! This home is a premier vacation destination. This home ...

    From $297 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Autumn Sky - The Modern & Relaxing Beach Cottage
    From $498 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Autumn Sky - The Modern & Relaxing Beach Cottage

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    8

    Autumn Sky Cottage is a fun and secluded get-away sitting in the middle of Beaver Island's Big Sand Bay beach. The Carib ...

    From $498 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Beaver Island, MI - Blue Spruce Cottage -
    From $249 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Beaver Island, MI - Blue Spruce Cottage -

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    8

    Tucked amidst the woods, just a stone's throw from the shores of Donegal Bay, is where you'll find this charming cottage ...

    From $249 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details