Fire Island Rentals
From $947 per night (USD)VRBO
charming beach cottage steps from the beach
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 8
A charming three-bedroom beach cottage in Robbins Rest, Fire Island. Steps from the beach, this cottage has a separate ...
From $947 per night (USD)VRBO
From $676 per night (USD)Expedia
Charming home with deck & outdoor shower- walk to beach
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 10
Tranquil Tides Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your des ...
From $676 per night (USD)Expedia
From $1305 per night (USD)VRBO
Bright airy Fair Harbor home with ocean views steps from the soft sandy beach
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 8
Hop off the ferry from Bay Shore and just a short walk to a peaceful airy lovely classic Fire Island simple home just of ...
From $1305 per night (USD)VRBO
From $895 per night (USD)Expedia
Charming Fair Harbor 3br steps to ocean, sunset view, WiFi, A\/C, outdoor shower.
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 8
Relax in a charming Fire Island 3-br gem in Fair Harbor. Nestled on tranquil Walnut Walk, this house offers a soothing r ...
From $895 per night (USD)Expedia
From $3456 per night (USD)VRBO
Fire Island Pines Oceanfront
- Bedrooms:
- 6
- Bathrooms:
- 5
- Sleeps:
- 10
An exquisite architect-designed private compound situated behind a large dune on the East End of the Pines, the home ble ...
From $3456 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1297 per night (USD)VRBO
Pristine 7BR 4.5BA house w\/ heated Pool at Fire Island Pines 500' to ocean
- Bedrooms:
- 5
- Bathrooms:
- 7
- Sleeps:
- 14
Located in Fire Island Pines, enjoy what this 7-bedroom house has to offer. With 1 king bed, 2 twinXL beds and 5 queen b ...
From $1297 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1419 per night (USD)VRBO
Spacious 5-bedroom house with central air on Fire Island’s wonderful Ocean Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 5
- Sleeps:
- 12
Family-friendly house with everything you need for a great beach vacation. Enjoy grilling and hanging out on the spacio ...
From $1419 per night (USD)VRBO
From $2750 per night (USD)VRBO
Oceanfront in Fire Island Pines
- Bedrooms:
- 4
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 6
This architect-designed oceanfront was built in 2016 and features 12' ceilings on the main level and 10' ceilings on the ...
From $2750 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1020 per night (USD)VRBO
Beach front 2-bedroom - Fire Island Pines - 30 day min. stay
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 4
Get away to one of the worlds most idealic gay beachfront resort towns. There's no place quite like Fire Island Pines a ...
From $1020 per night (USD)VRBO
From $895 per night (USD)Expedia
Oceanside Writer’s Retreat, Steps from the Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 6
Unwind in Sayville at this lovely house. Nestled in a serene neighborhood, this marvelous property offers a charming esc ...
From $895 per night (USD)Expedia
From $1949 per night (USD)VRBO
Horace Gifford Design - Modernist Gem on Fire Island - Pines
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 6
Escape to this pleasant house in picturesque Fire Island. This charming vacation rental offers a soothing retreat for gu ...
From $1949 per night (USD)VRBO
From $981 per night (USD)Expedia
Beach House
- Bedrooms:
- 5
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 14
Perfect beach house! Ocean and bay access from just across the street. Private beach and public beach just steps away. S ...
From $981 per night (USD)Expedia
From $1449 per night (USD)VRBO
Newly renovated 4 bed 2 bath close to bay and beach
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 8
Your Saltaire, Fire Island adventure begins at this 4-bedroom house. Marvelous and cool, this property offers a serene e ...
From $1449 per night (USD)VRBO
From $2713 per night (USD)Expedia
Recently Renovated and Re-Designed Westhampton Beach Home, Amazing Water...
- Bedrooms:
- 6
- Bathrooms:
- 5
- Sleeps:
- 10
The Dune Desire Recently Renovated and Re-Designed Westhampton Beach Home, Amazing Water Views, Perfect for Families 5 ...
From $2713 per night (USD)Expedia
From $1755 per night (USD)VRBO
Pool, Central AC, 4 bedroom 2.5 baths in Spectacular Seaview.
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 6
Fall asleep to the crashing waves. Experience the ideal summer escape in Seaview! This pet-friendly summer abode boasts ...
From $1755 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1094 per night (USD)Expedia
Charming 3-bedroom house with WiFi, CAC in welcoming Ocean Beach on Fire Island
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 6
RENTALS ARE MONDAY NOON THRU SUNDAY NOON ONLY (6nights minimum/maximum) Get ready to relax in our 3-bedroom family frien ...
From $1094 per night (USD)Expedia
Click For PricingVRBO
Spacious 4-bedroom house in superb Fire Island with WiFi, AC
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 6
Get ready to relax in this 4-bedroom house in Fire Island. This delightful property offers everything you need for a won ...
Click For PricingVRBO
From $485 per night (USD)Expedia
Beachy cottage steps from ocean with A\/C & outdoor shower
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 2
Coastal Cove Cottage Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter y ...
From $485 per night (USD)Expedia
Click For PricingVRBO
Steps from the beach. 5-bedroom house in charming Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY.
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 5
- Sleeps:
- 10
This fantastic house in Ocean Beach offers 5 bedrooms, including 1 full bed and 9 twin beds. With 2 full bathrooms and a ...
Click For PricingVRBO
Click For PricingExpedia
Davis Park, pet-friendly 4-bedroom house; AC w\/ full views of both Bay and Ocean
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 8
This open floor plan beach house offers breathtaking views of both the Great South Bay and Atlantic Ocean. 4 bedrooms; k ...
Click For PricingExpedia
From $1580 per night (USD)VRBO
Oceanfront renovated home in FI Pines, stunning views & spacious outdoor oasis
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 8
Your Fire Island Pines Paradise awaits with oceanfront bliss and endless memories. Escape to this stunning 4-bedroom ha ...
From $1580 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1005 per night (USD)VRBO
Unique multi-level, private tree house w\/pool, close to town,1 block to ocean.
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 6
Escape to an enchanting 3-bedroom house in Fire Island Pines. This unique, multi-level tree house sits on the crest of ...
From $1005 per night (USD)VRBO
From $898 per night (USD)VRBO
Charming 3-bedroom house with AC and WiFi in the Pines
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 6
Newly renovated 3 bedroom home in the Pines in a very private setting. The house is arranged around a large outdoor cour ...
From $898 per night (USD)VRBO
From $3796 per night (USD)VRBO
Terrific 4-bedroom house in Fire Island Pines with WiFi
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 8
Escape to this lovely house in picturesque Fire Island Pines. With 4 bedrooms, including 2 twin beds, and 2 bathrooms, t ...
From $3796 per night (USD)VRBO
From $2102 per night (USD)VRBO
Enchanting 4-bedroom house in Fire Island Pines with WiFi
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 8
Discover this 4-bedroom gem in Fire Island Pines. This adorable house features 3 king beds and 1 queen bed, perfect for ...
From $2102 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1028 per night (USD)VRBO
Pleasant 3-bedroom house in Fire Island Pines with WiFi
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 6
Discover the beauty of Fire Island Pines from this 3-bedroom house. This wonderful property features 2 queen beds and 1 ...
From $1028 per night (USD)VRBO
From $286 per night (USD)VRBO
Charming 4-bedroom house with AC and WiFi in lovely Sayville
- Bedrooms:
- 4
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 6
Stay comfortably in Sayville at this 4-bedroom house. Each bedroom offers a nice mix of sleeping arrangements with 1 twi ...
From $286 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1019 per night (USD)VRBO
Lovely 3-bedroom house in Fire Island Pines with WiFi
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 6
Discover this 3-bedroom gem in Fire Island Pines. This beautiful house features 3 queen beds and 2 bathrooms, perfect fo ...
From $1019 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1008 per night (USD)VRBO
Treetop Beach House with Amazing Views of Bay & Ocean in Davis Park, Fire Island
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 8
This Fire Island beach house, in the Ocean Ridge section of Davis Park, features amazing panoramic views of both the Atl ...
From $1008 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1037 per night (USD)VRBO
OceanFront Davis Park FI Split AC Sleeps 10, EXPANSIVE OCEAN FRONT VIEWS LARGE DECKS NEWLY RENOVATED
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 12
Newly renovated Ocean Front Charming beach house brand new to market in Ocean Ridge Section of Davis Park, Fire Island C ...
From $1037 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1095 per night (USD)VRBO
Mint Oceanfront Fire Island Pines 2 BR\/2 bath Co-op
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 4
Located in Fire Island Pines, NY, this oceanfront co-op residence is a dream overlooking the sand and surf. With 2 bedr ...
From $1095 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1897 per night (USD)Expedia
Spacious 5-bedroom house in Ocean Beach with Heated Saltwater Pool!!
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 5
- Sleeps:
- 14
Introducing 'THE REEF' This Ocean Beach property will surely impress. With five bedrooms, including two king beds, thi ...
From $1897 per night (USD)Expedia
From $1324 per night (USD)VRBO
3BR\/2.5bath Ocean View Home in Fire Island Pines with heated pool
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 6
Fire Island Pines home with expansive ocean views and heated pool. Main floor living area is open plan with air conditio ...
From $1324 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1642 per night (USD)Expedia
Oceanfront, beautiful 4-bedroom house in Fire Island. Panoramic views.
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 8
Escape to The Round House, a one of a kind home in picturesque Ocean Beach, Fire Island. Steps from the beach. guests c ...
From $1642 per night (USD)Expedia
From $1002 per night (USD)VRBO
Charming, freshly updated 3-bedroom house in superb Ocean Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 6
Nestled in Ocean Beach, this delightful house located north of midway offers 3 bedrooms - 2 with queen beds and 1 with a ...
From $1002 per night (USD)VRBO
From $2892 per night (USD)VRBO
FIP Modern Beach House
- Bedrooms:
- 4
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 6
Welcome to Beachcomber Grove, your serene getaway nestled in the heart of FIP, just a ten minute walk from the ferry and ...
From $2892 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1154 per night (USD)VRBO
Very private, luxury oceanfront home on Fire Island, NY.
- Bedrooms:
- 4
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 7
Luxury oceanfront home with two large decks, nestled into the national seashore with 100 undeveloped acres on the east s ...
From $1154 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1009 per night (USD)VRBO
Large Property With Spacious Deck
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 8
Charming two story beach house one half block from town and one and a half blocks from the beach. Ocean Beach is reache ...
From $1009 per night (USD)VRBO
From $2491 per night (USD)VRBO
Spacious 6 Bedroom 6.5 Bath Pines house on the Bay w\/AC, Heated Pool & Hot Tub
- Bedrooms:
- 7
- Bathrooms:
- 6
- Sleeps:
- 12
Experience the epitome of Fire Island Pines bay-front living in this exquisite residence overlooking the Great South Bay ...
From $2491 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1814 per night (USD)VRBO
New House: 3 bedrooms with Pool, WiFi, A\/C, Bay Views & Rooftop Deck in FI Pines
- Bedrooms:
- 4
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 8
About this space: The Perfect Pines Retreat! This brand-new beach house is just 4 houses from the beach and offers 3 spa ...
From $1814 per night (USD)VRBO
From $2570 per night (USD)VRBO
Gatsby's - Heated Plunge Pool & Hot Tub in OBP, Sleeps 24, Steps From The Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 5
- Bathrooms:
- 7
- Sleeps:
- 24
One Of The Few Homes That Can Accommodate Your Entire Group of 16 or more! 3 Day Minimum Booking, Reduced Rate For Week ...
From $2570 per night (USD)VRBO
From $3142 per night (USD)VRBO
Fire Island Beach House with Full Size Pool and Hot Tub-4 Houses from the Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 4
- Bathrooms:
- 6
- Sleeps:
- 15
Welcome to The Twin Fin! A Spacious Beachside Retreat 4 Houses Off the Ocean with Pool & Hot Tub in Ocean Bay Park Esca ...
From $3142 per night (USD)VRBO
Click For PricingVRBO
Cozy beach home with deck, grill, outdoor shower - 1 block to beach!
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 8
Family Beach House Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your ...
Click For PricingVRBO
From $1228 per night (USD)VRBO
4 Bedroom Spacious Beach House in Ocean Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 12
Stay comfortably in Ocean Beach at this 4-bedroom house. With 1 queen bed, 3 twin beds, 2 bunk beds, and 1 full bed, gue ...
From $1228 per night (USD)VRBO
From $743 per night (USD)VRBO
Charming 4-Bedroom House in Ocean Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 11
Stay comfortably in Ocean Beach at this 4-bedroom house. House sleeps up to 10-11. Great for friends or a family. Hou ...
From $743 per night (USD)VRBO
From $1469 per night (USD)Expedia
4 BR with bay views in Corneille Estates. Right next to Ocean Beach and quiet!
- Bedrooms:
- 5
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 11
Your peaceful beach getaway awaits in Corneille Estates located on Fire Island near the town of Ocean Beach. Corneille ...
From $1469 per night (USD)Expedia
From $1682 per night (USD)VRBO
Fire Island Pines Oasis w\/4 King Bdrms, Heated Pool, Hot Tub, Ocean & Bay Views
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 9
Kick back and relax in our calm and stylish Fire Island oasis with a warm and sunny open layout and stunning ocean and b ...
From $1682 per night (USD)VRBO
From $480 per night (USD)Expedia
Cedar Dunes, Gallery Bedroom - Luxury Beach House in Fire Island Pines
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 2
Welcome to Cedar Dunes! This owner-occupied house has 4 rental rooms (2 king bedrooms, 1 queen bedroom, and a double ro ...
From $480 per night (USD)Expedia
From $600 per night (USD)VRBO
CEDAR DUNES - Forest Bedroom in the Pines
- Bedrooms:
- 5
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 2
Welcome to Cedar Dunes! Since rooms are rented individually, this listing is for one room in an owner-occupied house th ...
From $600 per night (USD)VRBO
From $503 per night (USD)Expedia
CEDAR DUNES - Sunset Red Bedroom
- Bedrooms:
- 5
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 2
Welcome to Cedar Dunes! Summer weekends are always memorable in this designer house with plenty of common areas, such as ...
From $503 per night (USD)Expedia
Click For PricingVRBO
CEDAR DUNES - Ocean Blue Bedroom
- Bedrooms:
- 5
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 2
Welcome to Cedar Dunes! Summer weekends are always memorable in this designer house with plenty of common areas, such as ...
Click For PricingVRBO
From $1280 per night (USD)Expedia
Gatsby's - Upper Level Unit of A Dual Unit Home
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 12
Upper Level Unit of A Dual Unit Home. Whole House Rentals Are Also Available. One Of The Few Homes That Can Accommo ...
From $1280 per night (USD)Expedia
From $1504 per night (USD)VRBO
Gatsby's - Pool Level Of 2 Unit House - Sleeps 12
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 12
Main Level Unit of A Dual Unit Home. Whole House Rentals Are Also Available. One Of The Few Homes That Can Accommod ...
From $1504 per night (USD)VRBO
From $592 per night (USD)Expedia
Idyllic Cozy Cottage in Davis Park, Fire Island - Weekly Rentals Now Available!
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 7
Escape to your perfect getaway and experience the ultimate beach retreat on Spindrift Walk in Davis Park, Fire Island! T ...
From $592 per night (USD)Expedia
From $1130 per night (USD)VRBO
Charming Fire Island Pines 3-bedroom Treehouse
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 10
NEWLY RENOVATED FIRE ISLAND PINES home. This treehouse sits high in the trees in ideal location, only a seven minute wal ...
From $1130 per night (USD)VRBO