Lake Shafer Rentals
From $382 per night (USD)VRBO
Lake front house with beautiful views and walking distance to Indiana Beach.
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 12
Beautifully designed lakefront home with large windows overlooking Lake Shafer. Perfect getaway for family & group gathe ...
From $382 per night (USD)VRBO
From $273 per night (USD)Expedia
Unit #2 RV (Reggae Reef Villa)
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 4
**Lake Property Luxury with Modern Amenities** Our modern RV retreat, just steps from Indiana Beach Amusement & Water P ...
From $273 per night (USD)Expedia
From $263 per night (USD)VRBO
Key Lime Resorts - Unit #1 RV Retreat Villa
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 3
Lake Property Retreat: Unforgettable Getaway! (1 of 5 units available) Experience a stunning retreat with breathtaking ...
From $263 per night (USD)VRBO
From $304 per night (USD)Expedia
Key Lime Resorts - Unit #3 Key Lime Cottage
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 5
Experience our Lake Cottage Welcome to your tranquil one-bedroom retreat with a view that dreams are made of. Imagine g ...
From $304 per night (USD)Expedia
From $271 per night (USD)VRBO
Lake View Cottage - 2 Bedroom w\/Kitchenette. Family Friendly!
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 5
Your family will be close to everything when you stay at this centrally located resort. The 400 sq ft cottage is approx ...
From $271 per night (USD)VRBO
From $163 per night (USD)Expedia
Peaceful Waterfront Home - Close To Indiana Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 8
Escape to this charming 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom waterfront house retreat in Monticello, Indiana, offering a serene getaway ...
From $163 per night (USD)Expedia
From $378 per night (USD)VRBO
Key Lime Resorts - Unit #5 - 5 O'Clock Somewhere Lake House
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 10
Discover our cozy two-bedroom bakehouse (5 of 5 units on lake property) just down the street from Indiana Beach, offerin ...
From $378 per night (USD)VRBO
From $170 per night (USD)Expedia
Captain’s Shore: Lake level 3-bedroom cottage, perfect for swimming and fishing
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 6
This Monticello lake level cottage(one of the very few)with some of the best views on the lake, Captain’s Quarters, boas ...
From $170 per night (USD)Expedia
From $165 per night (USD)VRBO
One bedroom cottage - Standard 09
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 5
Bungalow cottages are small cottages that live large! One bedroom plus a sleeping alcove make a great affordable option ...
From $165 per night (USD)VRBO
From $165 per night (USD)VRBO
2 bedrooms Cottage -Standard 05
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 5
Bungalow cottages are small spaces that live large! One bedroom plus a sleeping alcove make a great affordable option . ...
From $165 per night (USD)VRBO
From $189 per night (USD)VRBO
2 bedrooms Cottage - Ensuite Standard
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 6
Single cottage is the full building with 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom. It also has a front patio. Blue Door Cottages is th ...
From $189 per night (USD)VRBO
From $165 per night (USD)VRBO
One bedroom cottage - Standard 08
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 5
Bungalow cottages are small cottages that live large! One bedroom plus a sleeping alcove make a great affordable option ...
From $165 per night (USD)VRBO
From $165 per night (USD)VRBO
One bedroom cottage -Standard 06
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 5
Bungalow cottages are small cottages that live large! One bedroom plus a sleeping alcove make a great affordable option ...
From $165 per night (USD)VRBO
From $189 per night (USD)VRBO
Two bedrooms Cottage
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 6
Single cottages are a very nice sized 2 bedroom in it's own building. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place for your ...
From $189 per night (USD)VRBO
From $262 per night (USD)VRBO
2 bedrooms Cottage perfect for a big group!
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 10
Our largest cottage that is perfect for a big group! 2 queen bedrooms, 2 king bed alcoves, 2 bathrooms and large livin ...
From $262 per night (USD)VRBO
From $125 per night (USD)VRBO
Studio unit with kitchenette
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 2
Studio unit is the size of a hotel suite with a kitchenette and King sized bed. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place ...
From $125 per night (USD)VRBO
From $123 per night (USD)VRBO
Studio unit with kitchenette
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 2
Studio unit is the size of a hotel suite with a kitchenette and King sized bed. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place ...
From $123 per night (USD)VRBO
From $125 per night (USD)VRBO
Studio unit with kitchenette
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 2
Studio unit is the size of a hotel suite with a kitchenette and king sized bed. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place ...
From $125 per night (USD)VRBO
From $189 per night (USD)VRBO
Two bedrooms Cottage
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 6
Single cottages are a very nice sized 2 bedroom in its own individual building (not a duplex). Blue Door Cottages is the ...
From $189 per night (USD)VRBO
From $189 per night (USD)VRBO
Two bedrooms Cottage
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 6
Single cottages are a very nice sized 2 bedroom in its own individual building (not a duplex). Blue Door Cottages is the ...
From $189 per night (USD)VRBO
From $124 per night (USD)VRBO
Studio unit with kitchenette
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 2
Studio unit is the size of a hotel suite with a kitchenette and King sized bed. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place ...
From $124 per night (USD)VRBO
From $217 per night (USD)Expedia
Lakefront Cottage w\/ Deck Near Indiana Beach!
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 4
‘Cozy Cottage’ | Dog Friendly w/ Fee | 3-Season Room | Gas Grill | Fire Pit Make this 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom Monticello ...
From $217 per night (USD)Expedia
From $285 per night (USD)VRBO
Waterfront Monticello Home w\/ Fire Pit & Deck!
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 7
Furnished Gazebo | River Views & Access | Gas Fireplace Relax to the ripple of the Tippecanoe River and savor gorgeous ...
From $285 per night (USD)VRBO
From $220 per night (USD)Expedia
Lake front Cottage 1 with Boat Docks.
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 4
Air conditioned, One Bedroom Cottages right on Shafer Lake with Boat Docks. The cottage has one full bed and one futon. ...
From $220 per night (USD)Expedia
From $220 per night (USD)Expedia
Paradise Cove Lake front Cottage 4 with Boat Docks
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 4
Air conditioned, One Bedroom Cottages right on Shafer Lake with Boat Docks. The cottage has one full bed and one futon. ...
From $220 per night (USD)Expedia
From $136 per night (USD)Expedia
Year round Lake home w\/wonderful frontage, nice yard w\/ fire pit, home theatre
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 12
Year round Lake Shafer Home, 3 bedrooms (king, full, twin) 3 bathrooms. Lakefront home just steps from the water. 120' l ...
From $136 per night (USD)Expedia
From $491 per night (USD)VRBO
Spacious 5 bdr Lake Shafer house with breathtaking view
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 5
- Sleeps:
- 10
With deck overlooking at Gorgeous Lake Shafer 😎 Indiana Beach Amusement & Water Park – 5 minute walk - Old school ico ...
From $491 per night (USD)VRBO
From $294 per night (USD)VRBO
Newly Remodeled Home on Lake Shafer with 120 Ft Waterfront
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 9
Great newly remodeled lake front property on Lake Shafer. this home has 120 feet of lake front. great place to swim an ...
From $294 per night (USD)VRBO
From $278 per night (USD)Expedia
Cozy Two Bedroom Lakeview Cabin 1
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 5
Two Bedroom cabin that has 2 full beds and 1 futon. Full kitchen including refrigerator, stove, microwave, toaster, coff ...
From $278 per night (USD)Expedia
From $241 per night (USD)Expedia
Charming One Bedroom Cabin 5
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 4
Cabin has one bedroom with a queen bed and a futon in the living room. Full kitchen including refrigerator, stove, micro ...
From $241 per night (USD)Expedia
From $201 per night (USD)VRBO
Beautiful lake house with something for everyone
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 8
This house has amazing views year round! With 3 levels of decks, a fire table, charcoal and gas grill, fire pit, lounge ...
From $201 per night (USD)VRBO
From $174 per night (USD)VRBO
Unit 6 on the water 2 queen beds
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 4
2 queen beds with full kitchen. Right on the water. Walking distance to Indiana Beach and access to the lake. Send the k ...
From $174 per night (USD)VRBO
From $430 per night (USD)VRBO
Amazing Lakefront House with all the Amenities!
- Bedrooms:
- 4
- Bathrooms:
- 5
- Sleeps:
- 10
Beautiful lakefront rental house. 5 bedrooms an office, sleeps up to 10 or more comfortably. Perfect space for entertain ...
From $430 per night (USD)VRBO
From $615 per night (USD)Expedia
NEW modern lake house + apt for 15: HOT TUB, beach, firepit, playground, games!
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 6
- Sleeps:
- 15
BRAND NEW lake house, custom designed for the comfort of large families & groups on vacation. This listing includes the ...
From $615 per night (USD)Expedia
From $310 per night (USD)VRBO
Completely updated Suite on the Lake
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 12
In this 1250-square-foot Suite you will find a private furnished patio including an impressive view of the lake, Priv ...
From $310 per night (USD)VRBO
From $268 per night (USD)VRBO
Penthouse on the lake, walking distance from Indiana Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 14
The penthouse is a second level 4 bedroom 3 bathroom apartment overlooking the lake. There are 2 pull out couches in the ...
From $268 per night (USD)VRBO
From $139 per night (USD)VRBO
Great 2 Bedroom Family Apt right across from Indiana Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 8
Upper level 2-bedroom suite offers a full eat-in kitchen, living room with a sleeper futon, HDTV and walk in shower. ...
From $139 per night (USD)VRBO
From $458 per night (USD)Expedia
WOW-modern NEW house on Lake Shafer: Hot tub, beach, firepit, playground, games!
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 10
Visit Piper House to enjoy the lake life, beautiful views, hot tub, beach, dock swimming, private playground, fire pits ...
From $458 per night (USD)Expedia
From $497 per night (USD)VRBO
Charming Cottage on Lake Shafer-optional Pontoon! Screened gazebo and swim deck!
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 8
Attending an event at The Lighthouse B&B and they're all booked up? We're a four minute drive from the venue! *Check o ...
From $497 per night (USD)VRBO
From $319 per night (USD)VRBO
On Lake Shafer Right Next To Indiana Beach's South Entrance
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 12
Rustic Two-Story Lake Cottage that sleeps 10-12 people. Large fenced in front yard and steps to dock on the lake in bac ...
From $319 per night (USD)VRBO
From $110 per night (USD)VRBO
Cute little Weekend Getaway for 2
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 0
- Sleeps:
- 0
In this room you will find a comfy queen bed, fridge, microwave, sink and bathroom. This is the perfect room for two pe ...
From $110 per night (USD)VRBO
From $172 per night (USD)VRBO
Waterfront Studio on Lake Schaffer, Walking distance to Indiana Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 0
- Sleeps:
- 0
You will just love our waterfront room. This room features a private furnished patio on the lake, 32-in HDTV, full kitch ...
From $172 per night (USD)VRBO
From $486 per night (USD)VRBO
Spacious Lakefront House, Walkable to Indiana Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 8
Newly remodeled lake house on Lake Shafer right next to Indiana Beach. Beautiful views of the lake with a dock for swim ...
From $486 per night (USD)VRBO
From $264 per night (USD)Expedia
Charming Riverfront Retreat in Monticello!
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 7
Leave the busy life behind and head to this Monticello vacation rental for some relaxation! This 3-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom ...
From $264 per night (USD)Expedia
From $453 per night (USD)VRBO
Adorable Lake Home on Lake Shafer-optional Pontoon, 2 Decks, great amenities!
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 10
Attending an event at The Lighthouse B&B and they're all booked up? We're a four minute drive from the venue! *Check o ...
From $453 per night (USD)VRBO
From $351 per night (USD)Expedia
Key Lime Resorts - Unit #4 Cheeseburger in Paradise
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 11
2 Bedrooms: The cozy space offers two bedrooms for your comfort. The first features a queen-sized bed, while the second ...
From $351 per night (USD)Expedia
From $663 per night (USD)VRBO
NEW boat slip and wave runner ramps. Great home next to IN Beach and Golf Course
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 10
NEW boat slip and wave runner lifts are now available to enjoy Lake Life at the Luse Lodge. It will leave you wanting t ...
From $663 per night (USD)VRBO
From $239 per night (USD)VRBO
3 bedroom Game room home 10 minutes from Indiana Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 7
Bring the whole family to this great place with lots of room for fun, just 10 minutes from Indiana beach amusement park. ...
From $239 per night (USD)VRBO