Mystic Island, New Jersey Vacation Rentals. Book Beach Rentals, Lake Houses, Condos, Cabins, Villas, and Homes in Mystic Island, New Jersey on RentalSaver.com!

Mystic Island Rentals

From $251 per night (USD)
VRBO
WATER FRONT BEACH BUNGALOW- SLEEPS 6 FIREPIT. GAME ROOM GAZEBO.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
VACATION RENTAL JERSEY SHORE, START BOOKING NOW!!! ADDITIONAL 10% off for FIRST RESPONDERS & MILITARY/VETERANS (MUST SHO ...
From $251 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $385 per night (USD)
VRBO
Watersports paradise, 65ft floating dock, bay in front, lagoon in back yard
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
12
Have it all for summer fun. Fishing, crabbing, paddle board, kayaking, boating, Jet Ski, swimming all from your private ...
From $385 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $217 per night (USD)
VRBO
WATERFRONT - Perfect location for a getaway !
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
6
Beautiful Mystic Island home located on the west side of Twin Lakes Blvd, a very short ride to the bay by boat via deep ...
From $217 per night (USD)
VRBO
Click For Pricing
Expedia
*New listing, waterfront home with two balconies, 18 miles to LBI!
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
11
Laguna Lodge has everything you need for your Jersey Shore getaway! Our home comes with Wi-Fi, 3 smart TV's with Amazon ...
Click For Pricing
Expedia
From $200 per night (USD)
VRBO
NEW REMODELED BUNGALOW!! Beautifully decorated on Lagoon in a great location
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Our newly remodeled bungalow is situated in Little egg harbor -Tuckerton area. This area is truly now up and coming yo ...
From $200 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $436 per night (USD)
VRBO
Family vacation heaven at quiet waterfront paradise at Osborn island
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Four bedroom dream get away vacation home at Osborn island. Enjoy quiet waterfront home and listen to birds wake you up ...
From $436 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $307 per night (USD)
VRBO
Three Bedroom Waterfront Oasis in Mystic Island! Bring your boat!
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
8
In the picturesque town of Tuckerton lies a cozy three-bedroom retreat perfect for your trip. As you step inside, you'l ...
From $307 per night (USD)
VRBO
$Pool, Waterfront, Jersey shore (W\/8 LBI Beach passes) Mystic Island Hideaway$
From $1600 per night (USD)
VRBO
Pool, Waterfront, Jersey shore (W\/8 LBI Beach passes) Mystic Island Hideaway
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
12
Waterfront home with your own Private inground pool. House is well maintained in a beautiful tranquil setting. Hang by t ...
From $1600 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $420 per night (USD)
VRBO
Lagoon Life - private dock and firepit
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
*There is a 4-day minimum rental requirement from the end of June to Labor Day* Enjoy all that this charming house ha ...
From $420 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $279 per night (USD)
VRBO
House Mystic Island Little Egg Harbor Living in the lagoon with scenic views.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Perfect place for making family memories. Scenic views of the Lagoon and minutes to LBI and Atlantic City. You will see ...
From $279 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $405 per night (USD)
VRBO
Cozy Bungalow on lagoon-10 min boat ride to the bay!
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Cozy 3 bedroom, 1 bath cottage on a quiet lagoon. Bring your kayaks, boat, paddle boards or just your bathing suit to g ...
From $405 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $914 per night (USD)
VRBO
Stunning 2600 ft² waterfront home, pet friendly, 8 person hot tub, rooftop deck
Bedrooms:
4
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
8 PERSON HOT TUB, MANY OUTDOOR SEATING AREAS WITH FIRE PITS,SCREENED IN PERGOLA! DOCK FOR FISHING, JET SKIS, BOATS OR JU ...
From $914 per night (USD)
VRBO
Click For Pricing
VRBO
Beautiful waterfront home with pool close to beaches. First time rental host.
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
8
Beautiful inside and out. Dock your boat on our Mystic Island waterfront property and bring your water toys and bathing ...
Click For Pricing
VRBO
From $1100 per night (USD)
Expedia
New Construction, Family Friendly, Waterfront!
Bedrooms:
4
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
15
Experience the best of summer in this stunning new waterfront rental centrally located on a peaceful lagoon between LBI ...
From $1100 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $502 per night (USD)
VRBO
Waterfront Mystic Island, Little Egg Harbor, NJ
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
12
Waterfront property that offers water views from the front and rear yard. Water toys provided in this paradise rental. T ...
From $502 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $319 per night (USD)
Expedia
3-bedroom vacation home 20 minutes from LBI, and 30 minute to Atlantic City.
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Escape to our charming 3-bedroom vacation home in the quaint town of Little Egg Harbor, Mystic Island. Enjoy the conveni ...
From $319 per night (USD)
Expedia
$Enchanting Mystic Island Beach Home on picturesque lagoon near Jersey Shore. \n$
From $400 per night (USD)
VRBO
Enchanting Mystic Island Beach Home on picturesque lagoon near Jersey Shore. \n
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
10
This stunning retreat offers a seamless blend of coastal charm, modern comforts, and captivating views that promise an u ...
From $400 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $535 per night (USD)
Expedia
“Surf Shack” within walking distance to the beach!
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
8
Beautiful 2 bedroom waterfront property within walking distance to graveling point beach! Enjoy a fully stocked kitchen ...
From $535 per night (USD)
Expedia
Click For Pricing
VRBO
Bayfront Dream! Spectacular views!
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
8
About this space Fish, crab, boat, kayak, jet ski and more right from your backyard! Take a break and come relax on the ...
Click For Pricing
VRBO
From $320 per night (USD)
Expedia
Into the Mystic. . . Getaway!
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Into the Mystic...You will know what Van Morrison was singing when you first step into this bungalow paradise! A cozy an ...
From $320 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $227 per night (USD)
VRBO
Cozy Waterfront Cottage Near Historic Town, Lots To Explore-Pets Welcome
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
6
**Thanksgiving Availability** In this lovely community called Mystic Islands (NJ) is located our cozy 2-bedroom waterf ...
From $227 per night (USD)
VRBO
$Waterfront Mystic Island Home w\/ Boat Dock!$
From $387 per night (USD)
Expedia
Waterfront Mystic Island Home w\/ Boat Dock!
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
10
Located in picturesque Little Egg Harbor Township, this charming vacation rental is the perfect base for your seaside ge ...
From $387 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $241 per night (USD)
VRBO
Mystic Island Bay Breeze, Beautiful waterfront sunsets waiting
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Beautiful waterfront home w/amazing views! Instantly you'll feel right at home in our newly decorated space. Backyard la ...
From $241 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $306 per night (USD)
Expedia
Into the Mystic...Escape
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
8
This home is shore to please and the perfect place for your getaway. Located right on the bay so you can enjoy all this ...
From $306 per night (USD)
Expedia
$Lagoon Front with Dock Family\/Friend Retreat$
From $446 per night (USD)
VRBO
Lagoon Front with Dock Family\/Friend Retreat
Bedrooms:
4
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
7
Family Oasis on the Lagoon in Little Egg Harbor. If you are looking for the perfect get away spot with a group of frien ...
From $446 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $317 per night (USD)
VRBO
Cozy Family Friendly Waterfront Property in Mystic Island, NJ
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
8
Serene Waterfront home in quiet Mystic Island of Little Egg Harbor! Home has dock for fishing, boats, and other water ac ...
From $317 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $530 per night (USD)
VRBO
Cozy Waterfront views 4 bedroom house in Charming Mystic Island - GUEST FAVORITE
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
12
Nestled in the famous Mystic Islands, this delightful house is the perfect vacation rental for guests seeking a terrific ...
From $530 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $307 per night (USD)
Expedia
Mystic Shore House
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
5
This home offers a great flow inside for entertaining or head outside to view the water and sit on the dock. You can vis ...
From $307 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $355 per night (USD)
VRBO
Waterfront Vacation Rental in Mystic Island
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Beautiful, Modern chic, and comfortable 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath waterfront property on a lagoon! Our home is newly renovated ...
From $355 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $463 per night (USD)
VRBO
Waterfront Paradise Near LBI and Atlantic City
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
🏡 The Space: 🛏️ Bedroom 1: Full Bed 🛏️ Bedroom 2: King Bed 🛏️ Bedroom 3: Queen Bed 🛏️ Bedroom 4: Queen Bed ...
From $463 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $457 per night (USD)
VRBO
Harbor's Edge Retreat
Bedrooms:
6
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Welcome to our exquisite Harbors Edge, a luxury home located right on the lagoon in the serene and picturesque Mystic Is ...
From $457 per night (USD)
VRBO

RentalSaver.com Compare. Rent. Save

Search Your Destination Now!

Mystic Island Rentals

Rental Rates ($USD weekly)

Guests

Check Rates & Availability:

Results: 31 Rentals

WATER FRONT BEACH BUNGALOW- SLEEPS 6 FIREPIT. GAME ROOM GAZEBO.

Watersports paradise, 65ft floating dock, bay in front, lagoon in back yard

WATERFRONT - Perfect location for a getaway !

*New listing, waterfront home with two balconies, 18 miles to LBI!

NEW REMODELED BUNGALOW!! Beautifully decorated on Lagoon in a great location

Family vacation heaven at quiet waterfront paradise at Osborn island

Three Bedroom Waterfront Oasis in Mystic Island! Bring your boat!

Pool, Waterfront, Jersey shore (W\/8 LBI Beach passes) Mystic Island Hideaway

Lagoon Life - private dock and firepit

House Mystic Island Little Egg Harbor Living in the lagoon with scenic views.

Cozy Bungalow on lagoon-10 min boat ride to the bay!

Stunning 2600 ft² waterfront home, pet friendly, 8 person hot tub, rooftop deck

Beautiful waterfront home with pool close to beaches. First time rental host.

New Construction, Family Friendly, Waterfront!

Waterfront Mystic Island, Little Egg Harbor, NJ

3-bedroom vacation home 20 minutes from LBI, and 30 minute to Atlantic City.

Enchanting Mystic Island Beach Home on picturesque lagoon near Jersey Shore. \n

“Surf Shack” within walking distance to the beach!

Bayfront Dream! Spectacular views!

Into the Mystic. . . Getaway!

Cozy Waterfront Cottage Near Historic Town, Lots To Explore-Pets Welcome

Waterfront Mystic Island Home w\/ Boat Dock!

Mystic Island Bay Breeze, Beautiful waterfront sunsets waiting

Into the Mystic...Escape

Lagoon Front with Dock Family\/Friend Retreat

Cozy Family Friendly Waterfront Property in Mystic Island, NJ

Cozy Waterfront views 4 bedroom house in Charming Mystic Island - GUEST FAVORITE

Mystic Shore House

Waterfront Vacation Rental in Mystic Island

Waterfront Paradise Near LBI and Atlantic City

Harbor's Edge Retreat